Loading

Official vs Bootleg: Alphamax Hatsune Miku - LampOfficial vs Bootleg: Alphamax Hatsune Miku - LampMisc

tharglettharglet20 days ago
This figure was a relatively popular pick, with three votes. The people who voted for her were NAYANMORI, ELISE_GRIMWALD and TAIGAPAWS. So I hope you'll enjoy this article!

This Miku is one of the few in my collection - I was drawn to the relatively unique theming of this figure and the strong green/orange colours. So let's see what the bootleggers have done to this figure and if it can come close to the original.

Pricing
MSRP (without tax): ¥3,800
Price I paid for the official (inc shipping): AUD$60 (£34.58)
Price I paid for the bootleg (inc shipping): $15.14 (£11.60)

The official I bought from another collector.

Box
Front:
https://i.ibb.co/Xyk9ZtM/box-front.jpg
What's this? A bootleg box that isn't obliterated? Rare!
The front of the box is a copy of the original. The colours on the bootleg are a bit different, most notable difference is the background colour.

Sides:
https://i.ibb.co/gzHsGBf/box-right.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/qkYDMYn/box-left.jpg
Again, these sides are 1:1 copies, though the colours haven't been calibrated correctly so the orange parts are darker and the black/grey areas are more browny in tone.
The print quality is a bit more fuzzy/blurred on the bootleg, but not as bad compared to other boxes I've looked at.

Back:
https://i.ibb.co/YcTGJCh/box-back.jpg
Yep, this side is also a duplicate. The mediocre printing shows up a bit more here as this side is largely product photos.
The barcode is the same - the sticker on my official is because the previous owner bought her preowned from AmiAmi.

Top:
https://i.ibb.co/dJHcS5h/box-top.jpg
The difference in colour is most apparent here as it is dominated by the background pattern. We can see the official was sealed by a piece of round tape whilst the bootleg was sealed with normal tape.

Bottom:
https://i.ibb.co/s2YDHmq/box-bottom.jpg
Nothing really to see here - both have the same flap pattern.

Inner:
https://i.ibb.co/MnmSB7D/box-inner.jpg
The bootleg's inner is a paler colour, plus the card is cheaper and doesn't have the shiny finish like the official. This part probably is the most different bit out of all the packaging.

The bootleg box is very similar to the official, with no edits made. The print quality and colours may give the game away in person, but most of the box flaws would not necessarily be apparent in a poor-quality photograph. So the box isn't necessarily a conclusive way of determining if you're looking at a bootleg.

Blister
Blisters out of the box:
https://i.ibb.co/nmQ3zHp/blister-both-front.jpg
The bootleg's blister is much more yellowy, and has started buckling. The official one has remained rigid, despite being pulled in and out of the box multiple times.
Looking at the bootleg's hair, we can already start to see figure defects without getting her out of the box, and we can see the lamp she carries is missing? Oh, no, wait... it's located at the bottom of the blister on the other side...

Figure blister:
https://i.ibb.co/GsBg2FX/blister-figure-front.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/55yBnDB/blister-figure-back.jpg
Even without the back blister, that bootleg blister is looking very yellow. We can also see the hair is a mess and the lamps are pointed at funny angles.
From the back we can see the figure more clearly thanks to less protective plastic and where that lamp got to - bootleg blisters are often flimsy, so accessories relocating themselves on "new" figures can be a bad sign.
We can also see the hair shading is a lot less distinct.

Back blister:
https://i.ibb.co/NpW7Xy8/blister-base-front.jpg
Yes, this is how the bootleg stand came packed!

Let's put the bootleg stand into its blister properly:
https://i.ibb.co/LpXr9Hv/blister-base-contained.jpg
The full blister for the stand was included with the bootleg, but for some reason it was packed incorrectly, which is probably largely why it got damaged in transit.
The stand blister is a copy of the official, but again, yellowed plastic.

Base
One of the nice features about this figure is the base - no plain disc here!

Front:
https://i.ibb.co/qDsjzb0/base-front.jpg
Here are the bases... plus one of the bits that broke off the bootleg whilst it was in transit. The other fence piece I couldn't find, no idea where that went.
The bases look overall similar, but the 'metal' fence parts on the bootleg are made from a more brittle plastic and are black instead of grey.
The bootleg's stonework also has an ugly yellow tinge to it.

Left side of the fence:
https://i.ibb.co/Jv15rDy/base-fence-left.jpg
Here we can see where the railings have a blacker and shinier finish on the bootleg with the way the light shines off the tip of the railings.
Looking at the railing curls on the left, we can see bits of excess plastic on the bootleg fence that aren't present on the official. We've also got some excess plastic fuzz on the top of the wall too.
Looking at the brickwork, most of the detail seems to have survived, but the dull paintwork hides the finer details.

Top of the left brick wall:
https://i.ibb.co/PwFV8Sh/base-left-wall-top.jpg
I don't think the top survived as well as the side - the cracks on the top two parts are nearly all missing on the bootleg.
If it wasn't for the weird greenish colour, the dirt effect on the bootleg bricks would actually look pretty decent.

Top of the right fence:
https://i.ibb.co/sbmwq8f/base-top-right.jpg
This side also suffers from excess plastic on the outermost curls.

Right wall:
https://i.ibb.co/dJqmndt/base-wall-right.jpg
Most of the detail survived on the bootleg, but the paint is sloppy in places - notably the dark grey bricks have a fair amount of green spillover onto them.

Paving:
https://i.ibb.co/JvwstTW/base-base.jpg
They've managed to match the darker brick patterns on the bootleg however the edges are sloppy here too. If they didn't go for such a greenish colour, this would look fairly decent. But they didn't. So it doesn't.

Pegs:
https://i.ibb.co/wLKKfQj/base-pegs.jpg
If you're yet to notice the horrible nubs on the bootleg base, here there are close up. Really not sure what happened here - was it that hard to correct the mould so the pegs weren't mere lumps on the base? Both the official pegs are much taller than the ones on the bootleg base and are normal peg shapes. Have we got another non-functional base on our hands? More on that later!

Back of the bases:
https://i.ibb.co/tz12mkt/base-back.jpg
Not too much extra to see here, but the paint on the top of the bootleg base has run down onto the edges. The official's are neatly painted in grey.
Can also get a good look at where the two of the spikes sheared off on the bootleg fence.

Bottom:
https://i.ibb.co/4JYKQP8/base-bottom.jpg
The bootleg has copied the mould exactly for the bottom so we still have all the copyright information. However, the bottom of the base doesn't fit into the upper portion correctly leaving larger gaps, and we have a variety of scratches and paint slop here. And that shade of sickly green.

The bootleg base is a valiant effort that manages to come close, yet is so far away. The cheaper plastic for the fence definitely lets it down as it can be broken easily. Bending the bootleg fence panel felt a lot more liable to breaking than the official one does, though I did manage to not destroy it more than it was in transit.
The off colours of the bootleg base ruins its appearance - just looks disgusting with the green tinge.
One visible difference that can't be hidden with poor lighting is the nubs - not sure why the bootleggers didn't manage to get proper peg shapes here, but as it stands it's a difference that would be fairly clear if the base is photographed separately without relying on colour.

Accessory
This figure comes with one accessory - her lamp.
Front:
https://i.ibb.co/7vT0mjr/lamp-front.jpg
The loop at the top of the lamp is smaller on the bootleg, plus it has been roughly moulded.
Moving to the body of the lamp, the top of it melds more into the top part on the bootleg. The bootleg also lacks any shading in the glass. Looking at the painted black detail, the paint is a bit thin on the bootleg.
Looking at the bottom tip, the official has a shiny finish, and the bootleg mould has gone horribly wrong, and the spike is quite deformed. The halves of the bottom don't fit together well either on the bootleg, leaving a gap.

Close-up of the top:
https://i.ibb.co/tKvKR0M/lamp-body.jpg
Here we can see the ring part also has a different finish on the official. Looking to the bootleg, we can see how the black line on the glass isn't painted as well.
With the lamp glass, the finish is more polished on the official - we can see the photography lights and the window reflected, whilst the bootleg's reflections are nowhere near as clear. We've also got some moulding defects in the bootleg, leaving hair lines going across the lamp's surface.

Close-up of the spike:
https://i.ibb.co/m4P4hfq/lamp-end.jpg
The bootleg's spike is fatter than its official counterpart. Both we can see a bit of the seam on this side on the upper half of the spike part. The difference in finish is quite noticeable here.

Overall, the bootleg lamp doesn't look awful, but it does lack the small details of the official.

Figure spin-around
Attempt no. 1:
https://i.ibb.co/MMF4J56/spin-fail.jpg
Didn't even have to stage this shot... this genuinely happened when I was about to take the first photo for the spin-around. Those nubs are indeed kind of useless - you can get her to stay upright with them, but if she imbalances or gets knocked she'll roll over and fall off. Yeah, not good.

Spin-around, for realsies:
https://i.ibb.co/pLYrfzn/spin-front.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/JtV5Nbq/spin-right.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/BrRP1wt/spin-back.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/5F34M2V/spin-left.jpg
The first notable thing is the bootleg's hair - it's a mess. It can be partly sorted out, but the curls won't ever match the official's as the inner parts are too short. I did sort the hair and lamp posts out on the bootleg after doing the photoshoot, but it still looked silly, just less so. We've also got more tan and shiny skin on the bootleg.
Looking at the bootleg's lamp it doesn't sit correctly in her hand - the loop is smaller than it should be which means it won't fit properly. This also means it can't use this as a direct replacement if you've lost/broken the official.
The bootleg's hair and lamp glass are also noticeably plainer.

Figure close-ups
Face:
https://i.ibb.co/MMM2F62/face.jpg
Looking at the bootleg's hair, it's slightly paler and has some rough edges - most noticeable to her left. The finish also has a slight difference, which can be seen how the lights reflect off of it.
The hair curl on the bootleg is tighter and the plastic is more see-through. The edges are also looking a little rough, with the tip of it not even pointy.
Looking at her face, the bootleg is a fair bit more tan. The bootleg eye prints are a bit darker and the print layers aren't properly aligned so the black and yellow have been shifted to her right. The lines that should be under her eyelashes are very off from their intended positions, making them look odd and out of place.
The mouth on the bootleg has an extra downward flick at one end, making her expression less happy than the small, cute, innocent smile of the official. Also looks like the bootleg's been eating warehouse dirt. Lovely.

Top of the hair:
https://i.ibb.co/ScFYkxC/head-top.jpg
Yep, the bootleg's hair isn't as smooth and shiny up here either. We've got some dirt included towards her fringe too.
Looking at the back half of her head we can see a litany of seams on the bootleg, whilst we can only see a bit of these seams on the official. The bootleg headband also has a seam, and there's a seam in the hair just above it.

Back of the hair:
https://i.ibb.co/Wy6777p/hair-back.jpg
First thing of note is that the bootleg misses out on the darker blue shading here, though the ponytails do seem to include the darker paint.
The dents in the hair from it being pulled into ponytails are not as distinct on the bootleg, leaving it a little unclear what's going on.
Looking at the headset pieces at the bottom of this photo the official has a slightly shiny finish whilst the bootleg's are matte.

Root of a ponytail:
https://i.ibb.co/gyB63Xb/hair-grip.jpg
Here we can see the official tries to match up the hair colours of the two parts, but the bootleg doesn't.
The hair grip itself is shiny on the official but not so on the bootleg. And yet another visible seam.

Right hair curl:
https://i.ibb.co/XWgVnNx/hair-right.jpg
Here we can see how the official hair has two curls that go down to nearly the same length as each other, and the colour fade goes around roughly half a curl.
The bootleg's inner curl is a LOT shorter... and isn't in the main curl! The lamp post isn't in there either - though it is possible to get both in if you want to. Still doesn't look good. The shading also doesn't even make it past the top of the lamp.

Closer look at the right lamp:
https://i.ibb.co/NnzFydY/lamp-right.jpg
The sculpting at the top of the bootleg lamp has gone a bit blobby and misshapen. We've also lost the shiny finish on the metal parts. The filigree-style details are thicker and more uneven than the official's.
Looking at the lamp glass there isn't any shading on the bootleg and it is a lot more see-through. I find the official lamp much more pleasing with its orange shading, giving the appearance it is lit.

Left hair curl:
https://i.ibb.co/BLxh666/hair-left.jpg
The official's hair curls are also a similar length on this side. Meanwhile the bootleg's inner hair curl is off... somewhere. Not sure where. Trying to hide in embarrassment I think.
This side also shares flaws with the other side - lamp post and inner curl not inside the outer curl, shading ending far too early, roughness in the sculpt.

Left lamp:
https://i.ibb.co/n8DmD67/lamp-left.jpg
Showing off all the flaws from the other side plus the filigree paint is only half there and the lamp is at the wrong angle.

Side of an earpiece:
https://i.ibb.co/y68XQcP/earpiece.jpg
In lieu of earrings, we have something that looks like an earring attached to the bottom of the earpiece.
The official earpiece is one smooth block but the bootleg we can see where the parts went together. The "earring" itself on the bootleg isn't painted fully and poorly cast.

Top of the earpiece:
https://i.ibb.co/9nh0hwp/earpiece-top.jpg
Didn't get a good shot of the official here, but hopefully still obvious enough the triangles here are neatly painted. The bootleg has a lot more slop and doesn't look very good. Also seem to be missing a piece that should cover the area above the triangles to the band on the bootleg.
The bootleg they've seemingly redone the sculpt - the three parts should be in a triangular recess, not recessed in of themselves.

Lamp:
https://i.ibb.co/zFQLLb9/lamp-in-hand.jpg
The official's fits over her hand so it looks like she can hold it. The bootleg you can get it to rest on her fingers, but it isn't a particularly secure fit.

Choker:
https://i.ibb.co/ZLR6pTW/chest-detail.jpg
The official's choker has been painted neatly at the top of the neck, with two circular details in the middle. The bootleg aims for this, but is very messy and doesn't have the shiny finish.
Looking at the top of the dress, the grid pattern has lost a lot of its shape on the bootleg and also has excess plastic. The green line on the top of the bootleg dress is also a lot thinner and not as neatly painted as the official.

Bottom half of the dress:
https://i.ibb.co/8P0Tw1Q/dress-bottom.jpg
The finish on the black parts is significantly different - the official gives a good view of my hands in the reflection, whilst the bootleg just shows off the lights.
The green paint is quite messy on the bootleg, not matching up with the sculpt and overlapping in places.
The details attached to the bottom of the dress show the same defects as the part up above, no surprises there.

Full front of the dress:
https://i.ibb.co/nrkPHB3/dress.jpg
Drink in all the defects on the bootleg all at once.

Side of the dress:
https://i.ibb.co/W3GYBH9/dress-seam-side.jpg
The bootleg's dress has an obvious seam that the official does not, along with the rose on her back. The rose itself is a much darker red on the bootleg and not as shiny.
We've also go one of the lamp posts visible on the bootleg due to the way it curves.

Side of the rose:
https://i.ibb.co/ZRrkRx1/rose-side.jpg
Yep, that seam on the bootleg rose continues around here. The leaves on the bootleg are sadder in shape and less vivid. They also seem to lack any shading, unlike the official.

Rose top:
https://i.ibb.co/bmYY30c/rose-top.jpg
The bootleg's rose is very much looking like Play-Doh due to the colour and rough paint texture. Official might not be the most roselike-rose, but does a better job than the bootleg.
Again, we can see the bootleg's leaves don't go out as far and lack shading.

Back of the legs:
https://i.ibb.co/RDqQgvw/legs-back.jpg
We've got the same differences in paint as the dress, again the bootleg's green paint is messily painted. The trapeze-shaped bits on the bootleg have been painted smaller. And the right one looks more square than trapezoid.

Feet n' panties:
https://i.ibb.co/VNyW79T/panties.jpg
Yep, they've both been painted under the skirt. Paint is looking a bit rough on the bootleg.

Ring connecting the lamp "post" parts together:
https://i.ibb.co/fFgjx05/lamp-ring.jpg
Bootleg was hard to photograph here, thanks to the messed-up hair.
The paint is a bit messed up on the official unfortunately, other than that, it looks decent.
The bootleg's ring has become misshapen and the paint is a mess, plus we seemingly have a random hole on the bottom post part. The inside of the ring has been painted brown instead of black too.

String tie on the post:
https://i.ibb.co/yYYTcpC/lamp-tie.jpg
The bootleg's paint is definitely messy here, and having issues getting over the mould line.

Post weight:
https://i.ibb.co/Sx7hJcn/lamp-weight.jpg
Bootleg clearly didn't know what was supposed to be going on here - we have the hole filled in and the end of the post? thread? doesn't go into the hole that isn't there. Something went quite wrong with the moulding of the bootleg weight, with the top edge curves not matching each other. Definite sloppy part here.

Conclusion
Telling these apart with just the box to go on would produce some distinct difficulties, as the bootleg isn't a half-bad copy. Once the figure is out the box, oh boy. The base is a sickly colour with inferior plastic for the railings. With the figure itself, the hair is an absolute mess and the paintwork is not good. Looking at any of the finer details will reveal paint mistakes and defects in the plastic/moulding. If the details didn't give it away, then the fact she won't stand on her base properly seals the deal.
Her hair can be sorted to some extent, but she still looks somewhat defective. The upper lamps aren't properly visible and the one she carries doesn't fit on her hand properly. Should imagine owners of this bootleg are probably annoyed at her propensity to fall over.
With her lamp ring not being big enough, this figure isn't a good parts donor either.
For all its faults, this bootleg does look passable at a distance, but definitely won't be gracing my shelves. The official one periodically comes up at a good price, so I'd definitely recommend saving up and waiting for that one.
1,036 hits • 9 likes10 comments

Comments10

bellechan20 days ago#91768366Great comparison!
The first spin-around try! Priceless XDDD
oh, Is there a poll to vote for next review? 'w'

Glad you liked it :). I'm not currently taking votes/suggestions right now I'm afraid.

fluffy_blahaj20 days ago#91786335That first spin around attempt definitely made me laugh. Great review!
Thanks :)

Elise_Grimwald20 days ago#91787476I'm glad you did this review, I was actually wondering if it would ever get enough votes for you to do one. I really enjoyed it. :)
Although there was no chance I'd have ever picked up the bootleg (given I've seen her on AmiAmi for not too bad of a price before), it's good to know what to look for when I finally do go and pick her up if I end up looking for her elsewhere. Which is inevitable lol. Thanks again for the review. :).

I'm working through all the things that got voted for and a bootleg was available :). Plus a couple of other ones that I picked up out of my own interest.
Glad you enjoyed the review.


dtindcarea20 days ago#91788940Cute Miku figure and I particularly love her drill curls! Great analysis as always and the fact that drill curls are different is a great observation and tell.
Thanks, yeah, those curls are very different on the bootleg, considering.


EsteIIa20 days ago#91804295oh this is my fav miku that I own! The bootleg is just sad to look at
Can agree with that - one of those figures where the bootleg just looks sad due to the good quality of the original.
19 days ago
oh this is my fav miku that I own! The bootleg is just sad to look at
20 days ago
Cute Miku figure and I particularly love her drill curls! Great analysis as always and the fact that drill curls are different is a great observation and tell.
20 days ago
Elise_Grimwald Genius Puppeteer
I'm glad you did this review, I was actually wondering if it would ever get enough votes for you to do one. I really enjoyed it. :)

At any rate, that bootleg is pretty bad (though not as bad as some of the other ones you did), and I agree that the paint is bad on her base. And the fact the figure fell down while trying to a turn around shows how little the bootleggers cared about the quality. Plus, the paint is pretty bad on parts. :/.

Although there was no chance I'd have ever picked up the bootleg (given I've seen her on AmiAmi for not too bad of a price before), it's good to know what to look for when I finally do go and pick her up if I end up looking for her elsewhere. Which is inevitable lol. Thanks again for the review. :).
20 days ago
That first spin around attempt definitely made me laugh. Great review!
20 days ago
Great comparison!
The first spin-around try! Priceless XDDD

oh, Is there a poll to vote for next review? 'w'
20 days ago
setokaibaswife ♡ Seto Kaiba's Wife ♡
Nice in depth comparison!
I thought it didn't look too bad until I saw the picture of the two figures in full side by side. The difference is striking and the bootleg Miku just looks kinda goofy.
20 days ago
migur20 days ago#91750291Idk if its me but your pictures aren't showing.
its just you, the pictures are working for me
20 days ago
migur20 days ago#91750291Idk if its me but your pictures aren't showing.

Grr, looks like imgbb is malfunctioning again. It'll more than likely be back later. Not sure how long it usually is down when they go down. If it's not fixed in the next hour or so, I can look at migrating the images at least temporarily.
20 days ago
Idk if its me but your pictures aren't showing.

Edit; pics are showing now!
20 days ago